Open source vs Open source
PostHog vs Umami: Which One Should You Choose in 1970?
PostHog is a open source Product & Web Analytics tool priced as free tier then usage-based per product, starting at $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based. Umami is open source, priced as open source (MIT) / Cloud subscription, starting at $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro).
Quick verdict
- Choose PostHog for
- PostHogproduct analytics, session replay, feature flags and experiments in one stack
- Choose Umami for
- Umamicookie-free, privacy-friendly analytics in a single Node application
PostHog vs Umami: feature comparison
| Feature | PostHogOpen SourceSelf-Hostable | UmamiOpen SourceSelf-Hostable |
|---|---|---|
| Open-Source Available | Yes | Yes |
| Self-Hostable | Yes | Yes |
| Self-Hosting Difficulty | Medium (Docker hobby deploy; production needs Kubernetes) | Low (Docker with Postgres or MySQL) |
| Pricing Model | Free tier then usage-based per product | Open source (MIT) / Cloud subscription |
| Starting Price | $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based | $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro) |
| Free Tier | Free 1M events and 5,000 session replays/mo | Free self-hosted; Cloud free tier with limited events |
| GitHub Stars | 40.7k | 40.1k |
Pricing takeaway
PostHog starts at $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based (free 1M events and 5,000 session replays/mo). Umami starts at $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro) (free self-hosted; Cloud free tier with limited events).
- PostHog
- Free tier then usage-based per product. Starts at $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based. Free 1M events and 5,000 session replays/mo.Full PostHog pricing breakdown
- Umami
- Open source (MIT) / Cloud subscription. Starts at $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro). Free self-hosted; Cloud free tier with limited events.Full Umami pricing breakdown
Pros and cons
PostHog
Visit PostHogPros
- Product analytics, session replay, feature flags and experiments in one stack
- Autocapture means events start flowing without a tracking plan
- Open-source core with a self-hosted deployment option
Cons
- Usage pricing spread across several products is hard to forecast
- A full production self-host is infrastructure-heavy
- Each module is shallower than the single-purpose specialist it replaces
Umami
Visit UmamiPros
- Cookie-free, privacy-friendly analytics in a single Node application
- Runs on a small VPS with Postgres or MySQL
- Readable dashboard for traffic sources, pages and referrers
Cons
- Web analytics only: no funnels, cohorts or product event analysis
- Thinner feature set than Plausible on paid hosting
- Limited reporting for multi-domain or agency setups
PostHog vs Umami: FAQ
Is Umami a good alternative to PostHog?
PostHog is a open source Product & Web Analytics tool priced as free tier then usage-based per product, starting at $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based. Umami is open source, priced as open source (MIT) / Cloud subscription, starting at $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro).
Which is cheaper, PostHog or Umami?
PostHog starts at $0 (1M events/mo free) then usage-based (free 1M events and 5,000 session replays/mo). Umami starts at $0 (self-hosted) or ~$9/mo (Cloud Pro) (free self-hosted; Cloud free tier with limited events).
Is PostHog or Umami open source?
PostHog is open source (github.com/PostHog/posthog). Umami is open source (github.com/umami-software/umami).
Can I self-host PostHog or Umami?
PostHog can be self-hosted. Difficulty: Medium (Docker hobby deploy; production needs Kubernetes). Umami can be self-hosted. Difficulty: Low (Docker with Postgres or MySQL).
Do PostHog and Umami have a free tier?
PostHog: Free 1M events and 5,000 session replays/mo. Umami: Free self-hosted; Cloud free tier with limited events.